I sell candy in my store and I like my customers to be "wowed" by the candy I sell. There is no doubt that these are very cute and will sell just because of that, but I felt like they could have been a bit softer and a bit more Cherry flavored. They weren't out of date, so they were fresh enough. They also have a very fine sugar coating on them which I wasn't sure I liked either. For the price and "cuteness" though I give it a 4.